2

When a question is asked it is usually tagged according to the problem. After an answer has been selected should it be best practice to edit the tags to reflect the answer?

| |
2

Generally speaking, if you find yourself in a situation where you're retagging a question due to the answers it got, the question was really tagged wrong to begin with. Tags like or are pretty steady-state. Can you give an example of an answer that you thought had a change in tagability from the question?

| |
  • 1
    Not necessarily change the tag but add them based on the answer. For example Lets supposed a question was about routing and was appropriately tagged with routing. If the answer turns out to be to use policy based routing should the tags be updated to include pbr as well? – henklu May 24 '13 at 19:28
2

It's a good intention, making the topics of answers more visible. However, tagging is for questions, not for answers.

For example, if a question asks about a Juniper firewall issue, but gets a good answer which uses a Cisco ASA instead, we shouldn't add a tag, since the question doesn't deal with it. Even if the OP would accept it and buy an ASA instead.

However, if you see that a tag is really missing to the question, possibly because the answer made the question topic clearer, go ahead and add it.

Another possibility is, that the question could be improved, without changing the specific scope too much of course, then a matching tag could be a good addition. In any case, the tag should match the meaning of the question.

| |
1

I think if the tags help to refine the categorization of the Q, then by all means. For instance, we have two tags here "wireless" and "wifi". Wireless description used to say it was for WiFi or WLANs, but I adjusted that as it was too narrow for a networking site.

I have been tempted to go back through the "wireless" tagged Q's to add "wifi" to those that are 802.11 related, as this would more accurately reflect the Q and help with future searches.

Edit: I decided to do just that for several that are clearly related to 802.11 wireless.

| |

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .