3

Following on from Aarons answer here, can I create a question like "What are some on line network engineering communities and how can I access them?" - Purposefully so that I can create a community wiki answer that people can add to?

So I am thinking of creating the question, the posting an answer with a list of mailing lists and web sites etc, and marking the answer as a community wiki for others to extend. Is this permissible within the Network Engineer rules?

1

I know that list questions are generally discouraged across the Stack Exchange network; however some communities allow them, e.g. Math... so I guess it's not completely out of the question, and its up to us as a community to decide; maybe the Community Managers have an opinion about whether it's too early to define such scope of the site, however.

Personally, I don't think this sort of post is for us; this is a Q/A board to answer specific questions, not a reference site for everything networking.

With this particular post, it's hard to draw the line IMO; what about geographical communities? Who decides when a community is large, helpful enough (to who?) to be added to the list?

Furthermore, these posts very quickly end up being a big, unwieldy list, generally without any sorting or organisation, and very quickly becomes unusable (can you tell I'm not a fan? :P).

As for how to do this; you can post CW answers right from the off, but to make a question CW, you have to flag it for moderator attention and specifically ask a moderator to CW it for you. Answers to a CW question are automatically CW'd upon submission.

  • +1, That is a good point about the scope of the list and who will moderate it and regulate the input etc. I guess it is asking for trouble. My reasoning is that it would save people asking questions about network engineering communities. – jwbensley May 24 '13 at 10:25
  • @javano: I would argue that those sorts of questions would be off-topic for this site anyway; they're hard to form without encouraging either a "big list" response, or subjective responses about which community is best / most appropriate. – Matt May 24 '13 at 10:30
0

no, off-topic

meh. CW/big-lists questions aren't a good fit.

...but what about posting such questions in Meta?

Search engines will still find it, and it will remain a useful resource for us to mention/link-to in comments/answers of normal questions.

I browsed through all the current meta questions and we don't yet have anything like this (a CW/long-list Q and As.) So we'd be breaking new ground as far as this stack is concerned.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .